Michigan Car Accident Victim With Fractured Ankle Has Case Dismissed
Under the Michigan No-Fault, law a person cannot sue a negligent driver for non-economic damages (pain and suffering etc.) unless his or her injury results in: (1) serious impairment of body function; (2) death; or (3) permanent serious disfigurement. MCL 500.3135. In recent years, Michigan car accident victims have had their cases dismissed due in large part to the Michigan Supreme Court’s misinterpretation of the “serious impairment” element in this statute in Kreiner v Fischer, 471 Mich 109; 683 NW2d 611 (2004). These cases have become known as “Kreiner Casualties” because many people with very serious injuries, (e.g. broken bones requiring surgery), have had their cases dismissed before they even get to a jury.
In McCormick v. Carrier, unpublished opinion per curiam of the Court of Appeals, decided March 25, 2008 [Docket No. 275888], the Michigan Court of Appeals upheld yet another dismissal of an injured person’s case involving a serious ankle fracture injury caused by a co-worker who backed a truck over Mr. McCormick’s ankle at work.
In that case, Mr. McCormick underwent two surgeries and was completely disabled from returning to work for one year. In addition, the evidence showed that his work played a very large role in his life, and he is “at another duty” because his employer did not consider him capable of performing his prior duties. In addition, his doctor and an independent doctor both found some indication of arthritis in his ankle as a result of his injury. Mr. McCormick testified that after being disabled for a year his life is “painful, but normal.” The Court acknowledged “that painful injuries, such as that sustained by plaintiff in the present case, do not generally disappear over time or necessarily improve with age.” However, despite these facts, the Court held in a non-unanimous decision ( Judge Davis dissenting) that Mr. McCormick’s injuries did not affect his “ability to lead his normal life.” which is part of the test under the “serious impairment of body function” threshold. In making this determination, the majority provided little analysis or reasoning for its holding. Unfortunately, Mr. McCormick’s case is only one in a long line of cases where injured people with serious injuries have been denied their day in court because of the Kreiner decision. However, based upon my review of the case law, until this decision there has never been an appellate decision (published or unpublished) where the Court has held that Plaintiff who had been disabled from work for a year does not qualify under the serious impairment threshold. In addition, this case seems to conflict with published case law that which holds that under the Kreiner test, an impairment need not permanent in order to qualify as a serious impairment of body function. Thus, the decision was a significant departure from decisions of previous Courts. In this regard, Judge Davis’ well written dissent illustrates the flaws in the majority’s decision.
Related posts:
- Michigan Car Accident Back Injury Victim’s Case Dismissed
- Michigan Car Accident Victim With Shoulder Injury Has Case Reinstated
- Court Dismisses Lawsuit Filed By Michigan Soldier Injured In Car Accident
- In Case of a Car Accident: Michigan Personal Injury Lawyers Release New iPhone App
- Michigan Uninsured Motorists Benefits: Michigan Car Accident Lawyers
If you would like more information about your legal rights after a Michigan injury accident, medical malpractice, wrongful death case, or other accident, you can order our FREE book, "The Ultimate Guide To Injury Cases In Michigan" by clicking on the book link. We will send it out immediately along with other important information.
For more information about Michigan injury and accident cases, visit our Michigan personal injury, car accident, and malpractice law website. If you would like to speak with one of our Michigan personal injury attorneys about your case, feel free to call us anytime at (800) 606-1717 or simply submit this contact form and we will get back to you quickly.
BUCKFIRE & BUCKFIRE, P.C. is a Michigan personal injury law firm and is not representing any of the parties mentioned in this article at the time of the posting of the article. The information contained in this article is from online news sources and any perceived misstatements should be attributed to those sources as we did not complete any investigation of the accident. If you believe that the information is inaccurate and would like it changed or would like this post completely removed from the site, please let us know and we will do our best to promptly accommodate your request. We are very sensitive to these requests.
If you were involved in this accident or a similar accident and have questions about your legal rights and options, it is important that you contact a reputable law firm. Please make sure that any Michigan law firm that you contact has significant experience in handling these types of accident and injury cases and has an excellent track record of successful settlements and jury verdicts. We also suggest that the attorney you contact provides you with a free initial consultation.
Categories: Car accidents,Types of Injury Cases,Uncategorized | Comments (0)| Permalink | Trackback |
Print This Post
|
Email This Post
