Michigan Appellate Decision Illustrates Potential Insurance Pitfalls With Rental Cars
At one time or another, all of us have purchased a rental car while on vacation, on a business trip, when our car is being serviced, etc.. Some rental car companies charge an extra fee if more than one person will be driving the car, such as a spouse. It is very important that all persons who will be driving the car, be listed on the rental agreement. This is because in many situations, if the car is involved in an accident, only those persons listed on the contract will be insured.
A recent Michigan Court of Appeals decision, Robinson v. Titan Ins. Co, unpublished opinion per curiam of the Court of Appeals, decided February 7, 2008 [Docket No. 275360] should act as a warning to all consumers that every person who drives a rental car should be listed on the rental contract. In that case, the Plaintiff went to rent a car. After filling out the paperwork, the rental agent informed him he had to place a deposit on the vehicle with a credit card. The Plaintiff advised that he did not have a credit card, but his friend, who had driven him to the rental facility, did. The Plaintiff’s friend came into the rental facility and, using her credit card, filled out the rental paperwork for the vehicle in her name. The Plaintiff was not named on the rental contract. However, the rental company knew that the Plaintiff was going to be the primary driver and handed him the keys. The Plaintiff thereafter left the rental facility, driving the rental vehicle. A few days later, the Plaintiff was involved in an accident with an uninsured motorist and was seriously injured. Following the accident, the Plaintiff made a claim for uninsured motorist benefits with his insurance company, Titan Insurance Co. Titan denied the claim, arguing that because the Plaintiff was not listed on the rental agreement, he was driving the rental car without the permission of the Rental Company. Thus, Titan argued that he was not covered under the insurance policy.
Fortunately for the Plaintiff, the trial judge, and the three judges on the Court of Appeals’ panel, looked beyond the rental contract and held that the Plaintiff’s case against Titan should not be dismissed. The Court held that a jury should decide whether the rental company gave the Plaintiff verbal permission to drive the car.
Although the Plaintiff in Robinson, supra will have his day in Court, the result could have been very different depending on the facts. Moreover, there is no guarantee that the jury will agree with Mr. Robinson’s argument and find in his favor. Also, this issue (and the trouble and expense of litigating it) could have been avoided if the Plaintiff had only been listed as a second driver on the rental contract.
Too often, people are seriously injured in auto accidents in Michigan and are denied certain rights and insurance benefits because of innocent mistakes like the one in Robinson, supra. Even if there is an extra charge to list a second driver on a rental car contract, it is better to pay the fee than to run the risk of being deemed uninsured and liable for much greater costs in the event an of an accident. This is because, when it comes to reviewing claims, there is no such thing as a harmless “technicality” from an insurance company’s perspective .
Related posts:
- Michigan Car Accident Insurance Coverage
- Home Modifications: Michigan No-Fault Insurance Lawyers
- Michigan Car Accident Lawyers Win No-Fault Appeal
- Michigan Car Accident Injury: Underinsured Motorist Coverage
- Michigan Motorcycle Accident Insurance Benefits Lawyers: Detroit, Flint, Lansing, Ann Arbor, Grand Rapids
If you would like more information about your legal rights after a Michigan injury accident, medical malpractice, wrongful death case, or other accident, you can order our FREE book, "The Ultimate Guide To Injury Cases In Michigan" by clicking on the book link. We will send it out immediately along with other important information.
For more information about Michigan injury and accident cases, visit our Michigan personal injury, car accident, and malpractice law website. If you would like to speak with one of our Michigan personal injury attorneys about your case, feel free to call us anytime at (800) 606-1717 or simply submit this contact form and we will get back to you quickly.
BUCKFIRE & BUCKFIRE, P.C. is a Michigan personal injury law firm and is not representing any of the parties mentioned in this article at the time of the posting of the article. The information contained in this article is from online news sources and any perceived misstatements should be attributed to those sources as we did not complete any investigation of the accident. If you believe that the information is inaccurate and would like it changed or would like this post completely removed from the site, please let us know and we will do our best to promptly accommodate your request. We are very sensitive to these requests.
If you were involved in this accident or a similar accident and have questions about your legal rights and options, it is important that you contact a reputable law firm. Please make sure that any Michigan law firm that you contact has significant experience in handling these types of accident and injury cases and has an excellent track record of successful settlements and jury verdicts. We also suggest that the attorney you contact provides you with a free initial consultation.
[...] post by admin Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and [...]
[...] post by admin Share and Enjoy: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and [...]